Category Archives: Reviews

Book reviews, movie reviews, TV show reviews.

Book Review: “Ordinary Monsters” by J. M. Miro

August 30, 2025ReviewsE.S.O. Martin

Ordinary Monsters, the first book in “The Talents,” J. M. Miro’s dark historical fantasy series plunges readers into a richly woven narrative that combines the sinister shadows of the Victorian era with a unique magical system. The series, which draws comparisons to Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children due to its concept of a school for gifted children, distinguishes itself with a considerably darker tone and a complex exploration of the boundaries between life and death.

Plot and Setting:

The story is set in a Victorian world where certain children possess the ability to manipulate “dust”—essentially, the dead cells from human bodies. These abilities range from self-healing to animating the dead. The protagonist and other children with these unusual powers find themselves at a mysterious school in England, led by a schoolmaster who claims to protect them from a malevolent former student. As the narrative unfolds, it becomes apparent that the schoolmaster may have his own dark agenda, possibly connected to a mystical doorway that bridges the living and the dead.

Themes and Characters:

Ordinary Monsters excels in its portrayal of complex characters, each struggling with their abilities and the ethical dilemmas these powers introduce. The children, each uniquely affected by their powers, are drawn with depth and empathy, highlighting their isolation and the heavy burden of their gifts. The schoolmaster is a figure shrouded in ambiguity, his true intentions a puzzle that adds layers of suspense to the story.

The series delves into themes of exploitation and protection, questioning who the true monsters are—the children with their frightening abilities or the adults who seek to control them. The manipulation of “dust” serves as a metaphor for the manipulation of the vulnerable, making the magical elements resonate on a deeply human level.

Writing Style:

J. M. Miro, with a background in poetry, brings a lyrical quality to the prose that enriches the dark atmosphere of the book. His detailed descriptions and the slow unraveling of the school’s mysteries are paced to keep readers engaged and immersed in the world he has created. The Victorian setting is not just a backdrop but a character in its own right, its foggy streets and shadowy corners mirroring the moral ambiguities of the story.

Reader Appeal:

“The Talents” series is not for the faint of heart—it contains graphic scenes and a brooding darkness that might not suit all tastes. However, for those who appreciate a grittier narrative combined with intricate world-building, this book offers a compelling read. It is especially recommended for adults and older teenagers who enjoy dark fantasy with complex characters and moral complexities.

Conclusion:

The first book in the “Ordinary Monsters” series sets a high bar for dark fantasy, weaving together an intriguing plot with thoughtful character development and a unique magical system. It stands out for its poetic writing and the ethical questions it raises, making it a significant addition to the genre.

Currently, there are two books in the series, but it is anticipated that there will be a third book in the coming years.

Book 1: Ordinary Monsters

Book 2: Bringer of Dust

As the series progresses, readers will undoubtedly look forward to unraveling the deeper secrets of the schoolmaster’s intentions and the ultimate fate of its extraordinary inhabitants. The blend of historical elements, dark fantasy, and rich storytelling makes Ordinary Monsters a series to watch.

If you like what you’ve read so far, consider entering your email to join my FREE Reader’s Club. Reader’s Club members will receive a free ebook, and also monthly emails containing book reviews, the latest installments in my “Slavic Spirits” blog series, and updates on my works in progress, and much more!

—

This blog post includes text and images generated with the assistance of OpenAI’s models. I provided detailed prompts, curated the outputs, and made edits, but the majority of the content was created with AI assistance. This disclosure aligns with my commitment to transparency under the EU AI Act.

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License. Portions of this content were generated using OpenAI’s models, with significant curation, editing, and creative input by E. S. O. Martin. AI-generated portions may not be subject to copyright under current laws.

Book Review: “Drive Your Plow Over the Bones of the Dead” by Olga Tokarczuk

August 23, 2025ReviewsE.S.O. Martin

Olga Tokarczuk’s Drive Your Plow Over the Bones of the Dead is a thought-provoking crime novel that blends elements of mystery with deep philosophical inquiry. Set in the remote Polish countryside, the novel follows the eccentric and engaging protagonist, Janina Duszejko, as she navigates a series of murders in her small community, bringing her own unique and often controversial perspectives to the investigation.

This novel is suitable for adults.

Plot Overview:

Janina Duszejko is an aging woman who lives in a small village in the Silesian region of Poland, near the Czech border. She spends her days caring for the vacation homes of more affluent residents, studying astrology, and translating the poetry of William Blake. A staunch vegetarian and advocate for animal rights, Janina is deeply troubled by the local hunting culture, which she believes reflects a broader societal disrespect for nature and animals.

The story takes a dark turn when several local hunters are found murdered under mysterious circumstances. Janina is convinced that these deaths are cosmic retribution, with the alignments of the stars pointing to divine justice for the victims’ cruelty. Her theories are dismissed by local authorities, but Janina’s resolve only strengthens as she delves deeper into her own investigation, driven by her convictions and her grief over the recent disappearance of her beloved dogs.

Themes and Characterization:

Tokarczuk masterfully weaves themes of environmentalism, animal rights, and the marginalization of women into the fabric of the crime narrative. Janina, as the protagonist, is particularly well-drawn, embodying both the wisdom and the marginalization often experienced by older women in society. Her radical empathy for animals and her disdain for the hunters are portrayed with a passion that makes her character both compelling and divisive.

The novel challenges readers to consider the intersections between justice, morality, and societal norms, questioning whether true justice can ever be achieved in a world that fundamentally disrespects life. Tokarczuk’s use of astrology and Blakean poetry enriches the narrative, adding layers of symbolic meaning that underscore the protagonist’s worldview.

Literary Style:

Tokarczuk’s writing is sharp and atmospheric, capturing the isolation and stark beauty of the Polish winter landscape. Her style reflects the novel’s dark themes, with a poetic density that demands thoughtful engagement. The narrative is interspersed with philosophical asides that invite readers to ponder larger existential questions, making Drive Your Plow Over the Bones of the Dead as much a philosophical text as it is a crime story.

Personal Take and Reception:

While the novel has been widely acclaimed, receiving praise for its depth and originality, it may not resonate with everyone. As a reader, you might find the plot predictable if you unravel the mystery early on, as I did. However, the strength of the book lies not just in the plot but in its provocative questioning of humanity’s cruelty towards nature and each other.

Conclusion:

Drive Your Plow Over the Bones of the Dead is a unique addition to the crime genre that will appeal particularly to readers interested in environmental philosophy and those who appreciate literature that challenges societal norms. Tokarczuk’s blend of mystery, philosophy, and poetic justice offers a compelling reflection on the human condition and the invisible moral boundaries that govern society.

This novel is recommended for adult readers looking for more than just a straightforward mystery—those who appreciate narratives that provoke deep thought and offer a critical look at human morals and behaviors.

—

Book Review: “Swimming in the Dark” by Tomasz Jedrowski

August 2, 2025ReviewsE.S.O. Martin

Tomasz Jedrowski’s Swimming in the Dark is a poignant and beautifully crafted novel that explores forbidden love against the backdrop of 1980s communist Poland. This debut novel, which draws comparisons to “Brokeback Mountain” due to its intense emotional depth and focus on a same-sex relationship under societal oppression, is both a love letter to Poland and a stark narrative of the challenges faced by gay men during a tumultuous period in history.

This book contains adult themes and is more suitable for an adult audience.

Plot and Setting:

Swimming in the Dark is narrated by Ludwik, who details his life from a nostalgic perspective after having left Poland. The story unfolds as Ludwik meets Janusz at a summer agricultural camp—a place meant for indoctrinating youth with communist ideals.

However, their shared discovery of a forbidden book, James Baldwin’s Giovanni’s Room, leads them on a path of romantic and intellectual awakening that is both tender and fraught with danger.

Their love blossoms in secret, set against the natural beauty of Poland’s landscapes, which Jedrowski describes with lyrical precision.

Themes and Social Context:

The novel is set during a time when homosexuality was met with severe societal rejection and state-level persecution, particularly under Operation Hyacinth, an actual historical initiative by the Polish police to register homosexuals. Jedrowski uses this setting not only to chart the personal trials of Ludwik and Janusz but also to critique the oppressive political system that sought to control the most intimate aspects of its citizens’ lives. The story poignantly captures the conflict between the private joy of love and the public demands of ideological conformity.

Character Development:

Ludwik, as the protagonist, is drawn with deep introspection and evolving awareness. His journey from a youth burdened by the need to conceal his identity to a man who chooses self-exile reflects broader themes of self-discovery and the quest for freedom.

Janusz, on the other hand, came from a rougher, more insecure background and he does not have a support network to fall back on. Therefore, he makes more conservative choices, even though it means turning away from love and authenticity. His character embodies the complexities of balancing personal desires, societal expectations, and basic security, providing a counterpoint to Ludwik’s eventual decisions.

Cultural and Literary Significance:

Swimming in the Dark holds a mirror to contemporary issues still prevalent in Poland and many parts of the world, where homophobia remains entrenched. Jedrowski’s choice to write in English and later have the work translated into Polish speaks to his intent to bypass local censorship and appeal to an international audience, highlighting universal themes of love, freedom, and identity against oppression.

Jedrowski’s prose is evocative and haunting, capable of capturing vast emotional landscapes with minimalistic elegance. The narrative is imbued with literary references and poetic descriptions that enrich the reader’s experience, making the physical and emotional landscapes Ludwik navigates palpably vivid.

Conclusion:

Swimming in the Dark by Tomasz Jedrowski is a compelling and heartrending novel that offers insightful commentary on love, political oppression, and the sacrifices required for personal integrity. Its historical context, combined with the universal themes of human desire and societal boundaries, makes it a significant read for those interested in historical fiction, LGBTQ+ literature, and evocative storytelling.

This book is highly recommended for readers looking for a powerful narrative that combines historical depth with poignant, personal conflict. Anyone interested in understanding the interplay between personal freedom and oppressive regimes through the lens of intimate relationships will find Swimming in the Dark both enlightening and moving.

—

Book Review: “The Witch of Lime Street: Séance, Seduction, and Houdini in the Spirit World” by David Jaher

July 12, 2025ReviewsE.S.O. Martin

David Jaher’s The Witch of Lime Street: Séance, Seduction, and Houdini in the Spirit World is a gripping exploration of the spiritualism movement that captivated America in the early 20th century. Jaher’s book not only delves into the mesmerizing world of mediums and séances but also centers on the intriguing battle between the most famous skeptic, Harry Houdini, and a prominent Boston medium known as the Witch of Lime Street.

Plot and Structure:

The book is set against the backdrop of post-World War I America, a time when the collective grief and the loss of loved ones fueled a nationwide obsession with spiritualism. Into this world steps Harry Houdini, the renowned magician and escape artist, who turns his critical eye and debunking skills towards mediums who claimed to communicate with the dead. The Witch of Lime Street, also known as Mina Crandon, emerges as his most formidable opponent, presenting herself as a genuine medium capable of astonishing physical manifestations during her séances.

Jaher masterfully weaves together a narrative that is as much about the personal journey of Houdini and Crandon as it is about the broader cultural and scientific implications of their encounters. The book details the Scientific American committee’s challenge to find a genuine medium, offering a substantial prize that drew Crandon into the spotlight and set the stage for her dramatic confrontations with Houdini.

Themes and Analysis:

At its core, The Witch of Lime Street examines the conflict between science and the supernatural, skepticism and faith. Jaher provides a balanced view, portraying Houdini’s crusade against spiritualism as both a personal vendetta and a genuine quest for truth. Similarly, Crandon is depicted not merely as a charlatan but as a complex figure who may have believed in her own supernatural talents.

The narrative also delves into the seductive allure of the unknown and the human need for consolation and closure in the face of mortality and grief, themes that resonate deeply in the post-war context. Jaher does not dismiss spiritualism outright but suggests that its popularity was rooted in a deeply human response to loss and tragedy.

Writing Style:

Jaher’s prose is compelling and accessible, rich with detail that brings the era and its characters vividly to life. He employs a narrative style that maintains the pace and suspense of a novel, making the historical account both informative and entertaining. His meticulous research is evident throughout the book, providing a solid foundation for the narrative’s dramatic and sometimes sensational events.

Conclusion:

The Witch of Lime Street is a fascinating account that offers a window into a unique period in American history when the line between science and the supernatural seemed momentarily blurred. David Jaher’s book is a must-read for anyone interested in the history of spiritualism, Harry Houdini, or the broader American cultural landscape of the 1920s. It is a compelling reminder of the enduring human fascination with what lies beyond the veil of death and the lengths to which we go to find comfort in the face of the unknown.

—

Book Review: “Kaytek the Wizard” by Janusz Korczak and “The Teacher of Warsaw” by Mario Escobar

June 21, 2025ReviewsE.S.O. Martin

Kaytek the Wizard, written by the esteemed educator and author Janusz Korczak, is a compelling tale set in Warsaw, chronicling the life of a young boy named Kaytek who discovers he possesses magical powers. First published in the 1930s, this novel explores themes of personal responsibility, moral development, and the quest for meaning, offering a rich narrative steeped in the realities of its time.

Plot Overview of Kaytek the Wizard:

Kaytek, initially using his newfound abilities for mischievous purposes, embodies the spirit of a trickster, exploiting his powers for personal amusement and causing chaos around him.

However, as he matures, Kaytek begins to question the purpose and implications of his powers. His journey takes a significant turn when he meets Zosia, a fellow wizard, who influences him towards a more altruistic path.

Together, they confront an evil mage, marking Kaytek’s transformation from a self-serving youth to a protagonist driven by the greater good.

Note: There is a Polish film version of this book – Kajtek Czarodziej

Janusz Korczak, The Teacher of Warsaw:

Janusz Korczak was not only a prolific writer but also a dedicated educator and pediatrician. He is renowned for his compassionate approach to child welfare and education, running an orphanage for Jewish children in Warsaw during WWII. Korczak’s life was a testament to his commitment to children, particularly evident in his tragic and heroic final days during the Holocaust. His profound understanding of young minds is deeply embedded in the narrative of “Kaytek the Wizard,” reflecting his belief in the potential and moral complexity of children.

Recently there has been a biographical novel written about Janusz Korczak titled The Teacher of Warsaw: A WWII Novel by Mario Escobar. This is a fantastic, but heavy, novel about Korczak during his final years as a teacher at the Dom Sierot Jewish orphanage in Warsaw. This is a heartbreaking novel about a terrifying and dark time in human history, and it is for adults.

Cultural and Historical Context:

While Kaytek the Wizard is a foundational piece of Polish children’s literature and predates many modern fantasies like Harry Potter, it is not without its limitations. Korczak wrote in an era with different societal norms and understandings of gender and race. The book reflects some of these dated attitudes, which may require contextual explanation for today’s young readers. The portrayal of certain characters and the dynamics of power may seem simplistic or stereotypical through a contemporary lens.

It is also important to note that Kaytek was written and published in 1933, during the interwar period, before the darkest days of World War II were about to begin. It portrays Warsaw during a brief time of relative peace, after Poland had regained its sovereignty in 1918.

Literary Significance and Limitations:

Despite these historical constraints, Kaytek the Wizard remains a significant literary work. It challenges young readers to consider the consequences of unchecked power and the importance of growing up with a sense of responsibility towards others. Korczak’s narrative encourages a reflective journey, not just through its plot but also through its moral and ethical queries, which are as relevant today as they were nearly a century ago.

Conclusion:

For young readers, Kaytek the Wizard by Janusz Korczak is more than just a children’s story; it is a philosophical exploration of growth, morality, and human potential. For readers interested in classic children’s literature and stories that offer more than mere entertainment, Kaytek’s journey from a wayward youth to a purpose-driven wizard provides a rich, thought-provoking experience.

This book is recommended for those interested in classic literature with deep moral underpinnings, and for educators and parents who wish to engage children with discussions about ethics, power, and personal development. As we read Kaytek the Wizard, we not only delve into a richly imagined world but also inherit the legacy of Janusz Korczak’s profound empathy and commitment to nurturing the inner lives of children.

For adult readers, The Teacher of Warsaw is an important reminder of how important it is for adults to be good, caring role models in the lives of children. We are facing challenging times, and in the face of this, we must continue to nurture and shelter our children with patience and wisdom. Even though we, too, may be depressed or afraid, it is critical that we be the adults in our children’s lives, and not shift the burden of responsibility onto their young shoulders.

—

Book Review: “Mexican Gothic” by Silvia Moreno-Garcia

June 14, 2025ReviewsE.S.O. Martin

Silvia Moreno-Garcia’s Mexican Gothic is a mesmerizing and chilling novel that redefines the boundaries of the gothic horror genre. Set in the 1950s in Mexico, this book combines lush historical detail with an eerie, suspenseful narrative that captivates and terrifies in equal measure.

Plot Overview:

The story follows Noemí Taboada, a glamorous debutante living in Mexico City, who receives a frantic letter from her newly-wed cousin, Catalina. Alarmed by Catalina’s claims of poisoning and ghostly visions, Noemí travels to the distant town of El Triunfo, where Catalina resides with her English husband, Virgil Doyle, in his family’s decrepit mansion, High Place.

Noemí’s arrival at the sinister estate sets the stage for a series of unsettling events that plunge her into the dark history of the Doyle family and the ominous secrets the house conceals.

Themes and Atmosphere:

Mexican Gothic masterfully blends elements of traditional Gothic literature—like the mysterious mansion, the damsel in distress, and the brooding atmosphere—with bold new components. Moreno-Garcia infuses the narrative with rich Mexican culture and post-colonial discourse, challenging the genre’s Eurocentric conventions and exploring themes of eugenics, racism, and colonialism.

The novel’s atmosphere is thick with a foreboding sense of dread that permeates Moreno-Garcia’s vivid descriptions of High Place. The decaying mansion, with its faded opulence and hidden decay, mirrors the rotting core of the Doyle family legacy. The setting is not merely a backdrop but a character in its own right, contributing to the story’s pervasive tension and horror.

Character Development:

Noemí Taboada stands out as a particularly compelling protagonist. She is not the typical Gothic heroine; she is assertive, intelligent, and fiercely independent. Her evolution from a naïve socialite to a determined survivor is portrayed with depth and authenticity. Noemí’s interactions with the enigmatic Virgil and the rest of the Doyle family draw her deeper into the mysteries of High Place and test her strength in the face of unimaginable horrors.

Writing Style:

Moreno-Garcia’s writing is exquisite, weaving lyrical prose with moments of sharp dialogue that cut through the creeping horror of the narrative. Her ability to balance the beautiful with the grotesque ensures that “Mexican Gothic” is not only a compelling read but also a disturbing experience that lingers with readers long after the last page is turned.

Conclusion:

Mexican Gothic is an outstanding contribution to the Gothic horror genre, offering a fresh perspective that is both culturally rich and engaging. Silvia Moreno-Garcia has crafted a novel that is as intelligent as it is thrilling, making it a must-read for fans of horror and historical fiction alike.

I absolutely loved this book, however it is filled with gaslighting, fear, horror, and some sexual content. Because of this, I think it is most suitable for adult readers.

If you’re drawn to dark narratives that blend psychological suspense, supernatural elements, and insightful social commentary, Mexican Gothic should be next on your reading list. Dive into Silvia Moreno-Garcia’s haunting world to experience a story that challenges conventions and entertains with its darkly rich tapestry.

—